Salt & Straw Ice Cream Review - Salted, Malted Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough (2024)

Table of Contents
Introduction Content FAQs


There’s a new brand in town, y’all - well, new to me, anyway. Can’t say it will be a regular feature, but let’s have some fun with this order! Any Salt & Straw fans think the pints are worth $17? If so, what flavors?


Enough for something entirely different I've had a few people, maybe even just one person, honestly, um, pop up in my comments, asking me to review different brands, outside of Jenny's.

So today, I have a new brand, uh today, I'm going to be reviewing an ice cream from the brand salt.

And straw I have been following these guys pretty much since they were brought to my attention.

However, I have been hesitant to pull the trigger on placing an order for a couple reasons.

The first is that salt and straw can have some really out there flavors.

In addition to like some very easily accessible and palpable ones.

They have put out flavors like, you know that have actual crickets in them or black licorice, which like personally is not my thing or like stuff like that they're, just, um.

They really are not afraid to push the boundaries of what like can be in an ice cream, which is great.

But the second piece of it is that they're also hella expensive, um salt.

And straw pints are like five dollars more expensive.

Each than Jenny's Pines and let's.

Be honest.

Chinese pints are pretty pricey in their own right.

So I was having a hard time finding flavors that were interesting enough to me to justify placing an order for the amount that I'm I'm paying for them.

But it finally happened I made a Black.

Friday impulse, buy I went onto their website.

They had a lot of intriguing flavors and uh, I, added them to my cart and I placed the order.

And here we are, despite like the Intrigue of the flavors that prompted me to place.

This order, um I'm going to be starting out with kind of a basic one flavor that I have for you today is salted malted chocolate chip cookie dough so we're going with an elevated cookie dough experience today.

Um, a big reason that I got this one is that my husband Mike.

He is more of like a standard ice cream, kind of guy.

He doesn't necessarily go wild for all these crazy flavors that I review and I wanted to get him in on some of this action.

And you know, get some flavors that he might be excited about so we're gonna try this one with salt and straw they're, um, they're, pretty No Frills.

We have a pint all their pints.

Look the same.

They just have the different flavors written at the bottom.

There's, no flavor description, there's, no flavor story.

All I really have to go off of.

It is the ingredients, um.

So because of that I had to go onto the website and pull the flavor description from their actual webpage made with the same malt.

You'd use to brew, Amber L.

Our house made cookie dough is perfectly salty.

Thanks to two types of salt, thick, malted fudge rounds.

It all out made with Jacobson sea salt.

And then I went to The Jacobson sea salt website and they're, basically, um like a bougie salt brand.

They have a bunch of different flavors of salt I have had the sitting out for about five minutes.

Now we'll say, I did a little bit of setup before filming.

Okay, um, there's.

No like plastic wrap to take off of it.

As soon as you open the lid, it's there, um lid did get a little bit out of shape, but we don't care about that here's.

What it looks like you see some of that yummy cookie dough right at the top I think I detect a Fleck or two of chocolate and is that a swirl I don't really know it smells like cookie dough like it smells straight up like cookie dough in the bowl once you've mixed it all together before you bake it very yummy let's, go in so I'm gonna try to get a little bit of everything here I've got the good cookie dough bite there, make it? Okay.

I think the chocolate chips are just like within the cookie dough itself.

And there are no so I was mistaken.

This is just a basic base with some cookie dough in it let's.

Try it.

My first impression is that the quality of the ice cream of the base is outstanding, um, which I've kind of gone into this being like, will it better be but the texture, oh, my God it's.

So smooth, oh, you do get that multi, flavor.

Damn that's.

Good this is gonna sound like a dumb thing to say about ice cream, but it really does like melt in your mouth like it's, like almost like it.

It starts to evaporate as soon as it hits your tongue.


The cookie dough is also outstanding like sometimes, you know, you have cookie dough and ice cream and like it hardens a bit because you know, it's frozen in ice cream, but it's because it was soft like it tastes like you just mixed it in the bowl too.

It is so good and I am picking up on the saltiness as well it's, subtle it's perfectly dumb it's, like, you know, a little finishing of the sprinkling of the salt on the top of your cookies, it's there, but it's, not in your face with grating of these I do kind of want to keep in mind.

The price point I want to kind of go in with the lens of is this worth the price right? Um.

This is an excellent flavor.

It's, not super original.

Obviously, um.

But I think if you're looking for like an elite chocolate chip cookie dough.

This is the way to go I, don't think it's worth 17, maybe be better off getting this at a scoop shop or something if you're near one, um, if you're already gonna place an order of other flavors that are maybe a little more interesting it's, definitely worth throwing this one in, um with that I'm gonna give it like a 5 out of 10.

it's, super yummy.

It gets high points for, um, just like the silkiness of the ice cream base itself, I'm really hoping to see more of that in this brand.

And the cookie dough is unmatched.

I haven't had cookie dough this good in any ice cream.

I don't think ever, um.

But you know, it's not super original and it's hella expensive.

So for those Reasons I'm, giving it a 5 out of 10.

and that's what we have for our first salt and straw ice cream, that's, the scoop I'll see on the next one I have to add an addendum to this video.

So I just went out in the living room to let Mike try some.

And he was like, yeah, it's.


And when he gave it back, um, I noticed that like the malted fudge the fudge that they talked about see, you know, if they put it in the description, I wouldn't have missed it.

He got like a fair amount of the fudge.

So oh, okay.

So texturally it's, giving dunkaroos chocolate icing.


Wise that malt is coming in again, I, don't know, that's as nice in the fudge fudge on its own I could do without I think fudge within the grand scheme of the rest of the flavor is good I would like to try to do, um, one bite with all of the elements.

I think, this is a good bite.

We've got the cookie dough.

We've got the malted fudge.

We've got the ice cream.

The fudge is okay.


Not my favorite element.

I think this just makes me firmer in my assessment of 5 out of 10.

Thank you for that.


Salt & Straw Ice Cream Review - Salted, Malted Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough (2024)


Is cookie dough in ice cream good? ›

Most cookie dough in ice cream is safe to eat because the flour has been heat-treated and the eggs pasteurized, thus protecting you from such foodborne illnesses as E. coli and salmonella that could be found in homemade cookie dough. The same goes for slice-and-bake and prepackaged cookie doughs.

Which cookie dough ice cream has the most cookie dough in it? ›

Buzzfeed just ran a not-exactly-scientific study on four major brands of ice cream to figure out which one includes the most cookie dough in their pints. And the winner is: Ben & Jerry's, with almost three-and-a-half ounces of cookie dough in a pint.

How popular is chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream? ›

It's a fan fave! In the US alone, fans scoop up over 1.6 million pints of Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough ice cream every year!

What flavor ice cream is chocolate chip cookie dough? ›

Chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream is a popular ice cream flavor in which unbaked chunks of chocolate chip cookie dough are embedded in vanilla flavored ice cream.

Does cookie dough ice cream taste like cookie dough? ›

The ice cream base tastes like cookie dough: Instead of a typical vanilla ice cream as the base, this recipe uses a combination of browned butter, brown sugar, vanilla, and chocolate chips to make the ice cream itself taste like cookie dough!

What is the difference between cookie dough and ice cream cookie dough? ›

Ice cream cookie dough tends to contain no leavening (it's unnecessary if you're eating the dough straight), the flour is given a heat treatment to make it safe to eat straight, and the eggs are, of course, pasteurized.

What is the number 1 selling cookie in the world? ›

These facts have remained true until today, making Oreo one of the oldest and most popular cookie brands in the country! Honestly, they're now the best-selling brand of cookies in the world. So as we can all agree, Oreo is the #1 cookie brand in the universe!

What is the best chocolate chip cookie in the US? ›

If you walk up any cookie aisle at any grocery store in the country, it is easy to see that Chips Ahoy! reigns supreme as the "#1 Chocolate Chip Cookie Brand in America" (per Chips Ahoy!).

What is America's most favorite cookie? ›

America's favorite cookie and the one dubbed “the American cookie” is the Chocolate chip cookie. Chocolate chip cookie is simply tantalizing both in flavor and in texture. The chips of both milk and dark chocolate provide you with a rich and strong flavor while the butter makes the cookies velvety.

What are the most popular ice cream Flavours? ›

YouGov asked 1,000 U.S. adults about their favorite ice cream flavor, and many Americans ranked vanilla and chocolate at the top. Closely following America's most popular flavors were strawberry, cookies and cream, and chocolate chip.

Is Ben and Jerry's chocolate chip cookie dough good? ›

Great Taste

this flavor is very good, the dough, the chocolate chunks, the vanilla ice cream. All together a very nice and refreshing piece of home.

What is the Oreo ice cream flavor called? ›

Oreo Ice Cream is also called Cookies and Creme.

Can you eat raw cookie dough ice cream? ›

To avoid infection, the CDC recommends not eating raw cookie dough or cake batter, but commercial cookie dough ice cream, however, is typically safe, according to the FDA.

Does frozen cookie dough taste good? ›

Generally, it's okay to bake these types of cookies directly from the freezer, but they will not turn out exactly like those that are baked fresh. The taste will remain, but the cookies will not spread as large. If you want the spread to be the same, we recommend thawing the dough for 24 hours in the fridge.

What does liking cookie dough ice cream mean? ›

6. Cookie Dough Ice Cream. You are resourceful and crafty.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Jeremiah Abshire

Last Updated:

Views: 5373

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (74 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Jeremiah Abshire

Birthday: 1993-09-14

Address: Apt. 425 92748 Jannie Centers, Port Nikitaville, VT 82110

Phone: +8096210939894

Job: Lead Healthcare Manager

Hobby: Watching movies, Watching movies, Knapping, LARPing, Coffee roasting, Lacemaking, Gaming

Introduction: My name is Jeremiah Abshire, I am a outstanding, kind, clever, hilarious, curious, hilarious, outstanding person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.